How are hazards and risks different?
A hazard is something that can cause harm. You can think of it as whether something is dangerous. Risk is
how likely it is that something might hurt us. For example, cars may cause accidents, which can be a
serious
hazard to someone involved in one. Cars can be very dangerous, but we may drive every day for our entire
lives without an accident.
This is because context also matters. Even though cars are dangerous, if your car is sitting in your
driveway,
your risk of having an accident in your car is very low. A car accident where cars are going 20 miles
per
hour
is not good, but an accident with cars going 70 miles per hour is potentially deadly. Risk is the chance
that a
hazard or danger could actually harm us. Our outcome depends on the situation and our exposure to a
hazard.
We can lower the risk of having an accident by making sure that our car is working properly, following
the
rules of the road, and paying attention to what we are doing while we are driving. There is still a
potential
for
harm, but we have lowered the risk.
Pesticide hazards and risks
In the case of pesticides, a pesticide's toxicity is its hazard. The hazard posed by a pesticide product
depends
on several factors. How toxic is the active
ingredient? How much of that
active ingredient is in the product? How toxic are the other
ingredients? All
of these factors affect the toxicity. The signal word on the product tells us the toxicity of the
contents.
For
more information see our fact sheet about Signal
Words.
Pesticides pose hazards either to human health or the environment based on their toxicity, but similar to
speed
in a car, context matters. Pesticides pose risks
to
people and other non-target
living beings based on if and how exposure occurs. We might be exposed if we apply or handle pesticides.
We
could get some of the pesticide on our skin, breathe in vapors, or eat or smoke before washing our hands
after
using a pesticide. If a pesticide is in an intact closed container and we do not open it, the pesticide
can't
easily harm us. It is a lot like the car parked in the driveway. The risk is very low. If we come into
contact
with a pesticide, however, there is greater risk.
An exposure to a pesticide that is higher in toxicity may be worse than having the same exposure to a
less
toxic pesticide. Also, your risk may be higher if you are exposed to more of a pesticide or for a longer
period.
Some pesticides are more toxic by one route of exposure than another. For example, there may be worse
health effects if you breathe in a product than if you get it on your skin. Therefore, the risk of harm
is
different
depending on how you come in contact with it. The formulation
of a
product can
also affect its toxicity and the way we could be exposed to it.
Risk assessments versus hazard assessments
We know that hazard and risk are related. Both are important factors in protecting people, pets, and the
environment from pesticides. So, what's the difference between a risk assessment and a hazard assessment
for the
same pesticide?
The U.S. EPA does a risk assessment on every pesticide
registered in the United States. Other federal agencies
such
as the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service also look at pesticide risks in some cases. Risk
assessments
follow a
four-step
process.
- The first step is identifying the hazard. How is it
harmful?
- The second step is estimating dose-response. How much is needed to
cause
harm?
- The third step is estimating exposure. Will I be exposed, how much
could I be
exposed, and how often?
- The last step is describing expected risk.1 What is my
risk?
Identifying the hazard involves determining if a pesticide could cause harm. In other words, how toxic is
it and
when would people or nontarget plants or animals be likely to come into contact with it?
Estimating the dose-response looks at what happens as exposure increases. The EPA considers single
exposures as
well as repeated exposure over time.
Estimating exposure is based on how the pesticide is expected to be used.
Finally, the U.S. EPA looks at all of the information
gathered in the first
three
steps. It evaluates the potential risks for each pesticide use. This process may allow a toxic pesticide
to be
registered, if
the pesticide's use is not
expected
to lead to enough
exposure
to cause harm.
What if new information becomes available?
The EPA regularly reviews information on pesticide accidents and reports of adverse effects. The
information may
lead to an updated risk assessment or new restrictions to reduce risk. If there is enough evidence
that
risks
are
greater than expected, the EPA may make changes before a scheduled review. Risks might be greater
than
expected
because the hazard was not well understood, or the exposure was underestimated. There may have been
ways
to
be exposed that were not recognized, or more exposure occurred than expected.
Some agencies place more weight on hazard than risk. For example, the International Agency for
Research
on
Cancer (IARC) works to identify the causes of cancer in humans.2 By only
identifying the
potential
for harm, it
does not consider risks to individuals in terms of both hazard and exposure. It is similar to
recognizing that a
car
is a hazard, without exploring how the car is being used. Only identifying a hazard ignores that the
risks could
be
reduced or even minimized.
Risk management balances drawbacks and benefits from pesticide use. We recognize cars as hazards but
avoiding
the risk of using one could have high costs. The U.S. EPA is responsible for determining what risks
are
acceptable
for proposed benefits.
For more detailed information about chlorantraniliprole please visit the list of referenced
resources below, call the National Pesticide Information Center, Monday - Friday, 8:00am -
12:00pm
Pacific Time (11:00am - 3:00pm Eastern Time) at 800-858-7378, or visit us on the web at
npic.orst.edu. NPIC
provides
objective,
science-based answers to questions
about pesticides.
Date Reviewed: May 2021
Please cite as: Gervais, J.; Hanson, W.; Cross, A.; Jenkins, J.
2021.
Hazard vs. Risk Fact Sheet;
National
Pesticide
Information Center, Oregon State University Extension Services. http://npic.orst.edu/factsheets/haz-vs-risk.html.
- Overview of Risk Assessment in the Pesticide Program; U.S. Environmental
Protection
Agency,
Office of
Pesticide Programs.
https://www.epa.gov/pesticide-science-and-assessing-pesticide-risks/overview-risk-assessment-pesticide-program
(accessed December 6, 2020).
- IARC's Mission: Cancer research for cancer prevention; International Agency for
Research
on
Cancer,
World Health Organization. https://www.iarc.who.int/about-iarc-mission/ (accessed December 6,
2020).
NPIC fact sheets are designed to answer questions
that
are
commonly
asked by the general public about pesticides that are regulated by the
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA). This document is
intended to be educational in nature and helpful to consumers for
making decisions about pesticide use.